Product work slowly turns into administration

I’ve started to think that one of the quiet failure modes of product work is that it slowly stops being about understanding reality and starts being about managing artefacts. You still have dashboards, KPIs, OKRs, rituals, reviews, syncs, planning sessions, grooming meetings, and an endless stream of tickets, but very little of your time is actually spent arguing with the problem itself.

From the outside, this looks professional, organised, responsive, visible, and constantly “in motion”. From the inside, it feels like being useful, shipping things, closing loops, keeping everyone aligned, and making sure the machine keeps running. Nothing looks broken and everything looks healthy.

But something subtle has changed.

At some point, product work stops being about doubting, observing, failing, and sitting with messy questions, and starts being about coordinating, documenting, prioritising, and maintaining flow. You spend more time grooming than questioning, more time syncing than learning, more time reviewing than being wrong. The job quietly shifts from understanding the world to keeping the organisation comfortable.

And this is not accidental.

Why organisations design it this way

This shape of work exists because someone designed it this way. Someone decided how often things should ship, how progress should be reported, how success should be measured, and how risk should be distributed. Leadership sets the cadence, the incentives, and the definition of “doing well”, and what gets rewarded is not depth of understanding but continuity of output.

Throughput is visible. Thinking is not.

What benefits most people in power is a system where work keeps flowing, roadmaps stay full, and no single decision becomes too legible or too controversial. It is much safer to manage ten reasonable initiatives than to bet publicly on one real problem and risk being wrong in front of the organisation.

And most PMs adapt to this environment very quickly, not because they are cynical, but because it feels like professionalism. You are being collaborative and a “good partner”. But in practice, you are learning how to survive inside a structure that quietly penalises depth and rewards coordination.

This is where product work becomes administration.

What it does to how PMs think

You start working with tickets instead of questions, with processes instead of hypotheses, and with updates instead of insights. You become very good at moving things forward, but increasingly disconnected from whether they should exist in the first place. There is a lot of motion, but very little intention.

Cognitively, the cost is that your attention fragments by managing ten projects instead of one real problem. You spend most of your time aligning, re-scoping, re-prioritising, and re-explaining, and very little time actually forming a point of view.

Reputationally, something worse happens. Engineers stop coming to you with questions and start coming to you with status updates. You move from being someone who helps them think to someone who helps them report. And that is the beginning of the end of a PM career, even if the job title stays the same.

The quiet agreement nobody talks about

What makes this dynamic so persistent is that it protects everyone who has power.

Leadership gets constant visible progress without having to make hard strategic calls. Stakeholders keep their initiatives alive without being told no. PMs stay busy without having to defend strong beliefs about reality. The organisation feels productive, even when nothing meaningful is changing. It is a collectively convenient outcome.

The uncomfortable truth is that most of us are not trapped by this system, we are sheltered by it. Administration is easier than thinking because it does not require you to confront authority, challenge narratives, or say “this is not worth doing” to someone more senior than you. It allows you to keep shipping without ever having to expose what you actually believe.

Over time, product work becomes a sequence of safe moves. You optimise for throughput rather than understanding and accumulate initiatives instead of making bets. And slowly, without a single dramatic moment, you stop doing product work and start running a product machine.

The job does not collapse. It just hollows out.

Thanks for reading! This article was originally published in my newsletter. I share one specific system for product managers every week. Join the community here: michelepm.substack.com